The latest MCU installment, Captain America: Brave New World, may not be the worst entry in Marvel’s expanding library, but it could be the most emblematic of the studio’s current identity crisis. Overstuffed, disjointed, and weighed down by reshoots, the film stands as a prime example of how the Disney+ era has diluted Marvel’s once-reliable cinematic formula.
The Cost of Disney+ Homework
A major issue dragging down Brave New World is the Disney+ effect. Instead of adding depth, the streaming shows have turned vital character arcs into ‘homework,’ robbing films of meaningful development. As the review highlights, The Falcon and the Winter Soldier stripped Sam Wilson of a personal journey, leaving his relationship with Isaiah Bradley feeling hollow and forced for audiences unfamiliar with the show. This issue echoes the narrative fractures seen in Multiverse of Madness, Quantumania, and The Marvels, where Disney+ tie-ins muddled the emotional stakes.
A Red-Hot Ross but a Cold Captain
Despite the title, Thunderbolt Ross (Harrison Ford) emerges as the real protagonist, with Ford’s heartfelt performance outshining the underwritten Sam Wilson. Ford, embodying themes of legacy and redemption, brings the emotional weight that should have defined Sam’s journey. Unfortunately, Sam becomes a bystander in his own film—a creative misstep rooted in the decision to tie Ross’s arc to The Incredible Hulk, a 17-year-old entry that few remember.
Reshoot Roulette and Exposition Overload
The film’s troubled production and extensive reshoots are evident in its pacing and structure. Giancarlo Esposito’s character, added late to replace earlier villains, becomes a wasted opportunity—relegated to delivering clunky exposition rather than adding tension or stakes. Worse, the final act collapses into CGI chaos, with the ‘secret villain’ reduced to a visual punchline.
A Glimpse of Hope Through the Meh
Despite its flaws, Anthony Mackie’s performance deserves praise. Mackie brings charisma to Sam Wilson, but his talent is buried beneath a script that prioritizes plot over character. Similarly, Danny Ramirez offers a promising turn as the new Falcon but is given little to do.
Conclusion: Marvel Needs More Than a Shield
Captain America: Brave New World embodies Marvel’s current struggle—too many cooks, too much ‘homework,’ and a heart that’s lost in the reshoot shuffle. The MCU, once defined by its heart and soul, now feels like a machine grinding out content without purpose. If Marvel wants to avoid further fatigue, it must prioritize cohesive storytelling over cinematic homework and rediscover the creative spark that made audiences care about heroes in the first place.
コメント